It was nationalised on January 15th, less than a month after the abrupt resignation of former Chairman, Seán FitzPatrick, fellow director, Lar Bradshaw who has been the Government appointed director of the Dublin Docklands Development Authority, David Drumm former Group Chief Executive, William McAteer, Group Financial Director and Chief Risk Officer, to mention but a few. McAteer is a former partner of PricewaterhouseCoopers. The current chairman of the nationalised bank was managing partner of that firm for a number of years. But the Government has failed to educate and convince the public that maintaining Anglo is in the national interest.
John McManus, has written a very compelling article in today’s edition of The Irish Times that argues the time has come to shut Anglo Irish Bank for good and the argument that it is too costly to close it is false.
No State money was invested since nationalisation but the begging bowl is out now. When the 6-month report to 31 March was issued on 29 May there was an immediate demand for €4 billion of additional capital. It was also signalled that further losses of €3.5 billion are anticipated. Anglo had assets of €101 million when it was nationalised. But the results at 31 Mar have diminished to €88.5 billion in a matter of 75 days since nationalisation.
The nation's capacity to bail out zombie banks is not infinite, nor is there much faith in their capacity to redeem themselves without extensive changes at the top. The National Pension Reserve Fund was valued at €15.5 billion on 31 March, having lost 30.4% of its value in the previous year. €7 billion of this has been invested in AIB and Bank of Ireland and if €4 billion is to be immediately committed to Anglo and a further demand for €3.5 billion is lurking in the shadows, the nation's sovereign wealth will amount to a mere €500 million.
The incidence of moral hazard is never far away when a fairy grandmother emerges to bail out an errant entity, and the former discipline of the stock market no longer prevails. It has emerged that Anglo made loans of €175 million to 10 directors and that €31 million of these are impaired. Would this impairment arise if the State was not involved and the stock market had to be impressed by the prowess of the business?
Apart from FitzPatrick who owes €106 million, Bradshaw, Drumm and McAteer the former directors were Tom Browne, Fintan Drury, Noel Harwerth, Anne Heraty, Michael Jacob, Gary McGann, Ned Sullivan, Declan Quilligan and Pat Whelan. The former board received emoluments of €11.5 million in 2008, a slight reduction on the €12.9 million doled out in 2007. But these far-sighted people decided that, had they remained, fees for non-executive directors would have been reduced by 20%!
This success of nationalisation is predicated on maximising the collection of outstanding liabilities. What signal is conveyed by a high incidence of impairment in the directors' loan account? There should be no directors loans whatsoever outstanding in a nationalised company.
The immediate call on State support of €4 billion immediately, is apparently to be made before the investigation of the Garda Fraud Squad and Office of the Director of Corporate Enforcement is completed. Impaired loans amount to €10.7 billion and a further €12.9 billion are deemed, at this stage, to be 'past due, but not impaired'. But they could be against this background. Loans of over €300 million, provide by Anglo to its own customers to buy Anglo shares, are now impaired and await the pleasure of the Irish taxpayer.
The cost of running Anglo Irish Bank, now a State enterprise is exorbitant. The average salary for the 1,753 employees for six months was €48,488 (equivalent to €96,976 per annum). A comparison with those public entities that engage with Anglo reveals that the average salary at the Department of Finance in 2009 will be €58,601, while the average salary of staff in the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions is anticipated to be €64,946.
The Minister for Finance advised that nationalisation would mean "drawing a line under past activities". As the Minister is the only shareholder, why was it even necessary to engage a public relations firm in connection with the publication of the first interim statement since nationalisation? If the intention is to signal the drawing of a boundary with life under the ancient regime, why would the new board of directors and not be bold enough to 'go for change' rather than choose Drury Communications, a public relations firm established by Fintan Drury? Drury was a former director of Anglo Irish Bank until June 27 2008. He was paid €85,000 in 2008 as a retainer to attend 4 board meetings and 6 meetings of the Anglo Risk and Compliance Committee and 2 meetings of the Nomination and Succession Committee. Surely there is some due out of a staff of 1,753 that could coherently articulate what is happening, or have all those with these qualities already resigned?
The Government has not done enough to convince the public of the systemic importance of either Anglo Irish Bank or Irish Nationwide Building Society. The McManus article suggests that since it is most unlikely to redeem its reputation. Customer funding has dropped from €47.8 billion on 30 September to €34.1 billion on 31 March – driven by “a market wide aversion to risk”. But is also reflects the decrease of €7.3 billion of customer deposits received from Bowler’s Irish Life Assurance Company that was designed to hoodwink stakeholder at the end of the last financial year – 30 September 2008.
Customer lending, to existing customers, increased fractionally from €71 million to €72.3 million and €700 million of this concerned capitalised interest and the roll-up of other interest outstanding. Basically it is a matter of endemic stagnation combined with a ruined reputation and an open-ended drain on public funds.
Ireland’s credit rating was reduced on June 8th to AA negative by Standard & Poor’s on account of the fiscal cost of weakening bank sector asset quality.
No comments:
Post a Comment