Showing posts with label Irish economy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Irish economy. Show all posts

Monday, January 16, 2012

Irish economy fragile despite higher tax receipts

Ireland’s Revenue Commissioners reported a €2.28 billion uplift in tax receipts for 2011, as a consequence of receipts in respect of the universal social charge and the public sector income levy.

That ought to be encouraging news except that the exchequer deficit in 2011 was over €6 billion higher than in 2010. 

It was in 2006 when Ireland last recorded an exchequer surplus.  Government expenditure since then has been €269 billion but tax revenue in the past five years were only €186.8 billion, leaving a cumulative exchequer deficit of €82.6 billion.

The reduction in exchequer receipt is reflect in lower VAT (-€4.75 billion), lower Excise (-€1.16 billion), lower Corporation Tax (-€2.8 billion), lower Stamps (-€1.79 billion) and lower Capital Gains Tax (-€2.68 billion).

Some €233 billion of the Government expenditure was voted while a further €36 billion was in respect of non-voted expenditure which covers costs such as interest on the National Debt – which reached €119 billion last month.

During the past five years the Government has reduced spending by a total €5.45 billion but spending in four departments, Health, Social Protection, the new departments of Public Expenditure and Reform and Health & Children caused an increase in spending of €6.55 billion.

The Eurozone convergence criteria requires the exchequer deficit to be no higher than 3% of the prior year’s GDP.  If this criteria had applied since 2007, the following circumstances would have applied:

Year

Actual Deficit €billion

Deficit permitted by 3% GDP
Eurozone Criteria

Overrun

2007

1,618.5

5,697

-

2008

12,713.8

5,397

7,316.8

2009

24,640.9

4,815

19,825.9

2010

18,744.2

4,677

14,067.2

2011

24,917.1

4,620

20,297.1

TOTAL

82,634.5

25,206

57,428.5

Public sector employment has been reduced from 320,387 at the end of 2008 to 302,769 in mid 2011, a cut of 5.4% after employment in the Department of Social Protection was increased by over 1,200 to oversee additional expenditure of €5.2 billion.

If Ireland is to meet the convergence criteria and continue State spending at prevailing levels it would require a GDP of the order of €830 billion, 5.3 times larger than 2011 GDP.  If that was to be achieved our GDP would equate with that of Indonesia (population 237.6 million) ahead of that of countries such as Australia, Holland and Saudi Arabia.

But if expenditure is to be trimmed to comply with the Eurozone criteria the Government will be limited to spending of the order of €37 billion, over €20 billion less than it spent last year but close enough to its 2003 expenditure.

Tuesday, March 1, 2011

Irish Department of Finance shortcomings highlighted

When Ireland became enveloped in an unprecedented financial crisis in 2008 it became clear that it had failed the test of prudent financial management,, which in turn, can provide a greater capacity to manage unanticipated outcomes.

Budgetary processes lacked coherence and ministerial accountability to the Oireachtas was weak throughout the previous decade. A lack of transparency was characterised by the absence of adequate information and analysis from the Department of Finance for the purpose of public debate and consultation.

An independent Review, published on 1 March, of the effectiveness of the 542-person Department of Finance is highly critical and portrays a Department as buckling under the reckless dominance and feckless political incompetence of Finance Ministers’ McCreevy and Cowen and Bertie Ahern Government. The Review also cites the invasiveness of political agendas including the PD-FF coalition Programmes for Government and the diabolical social partnerships which allowed lobbyists and their chaplain run riot with their unsustainable wage demands.

The Review covers the period this Department was in the charge of Secretaries-General , Hurley (March 2000 to March 2002 who subsequently became Governor of the Central Bank ), Considine (March 2002 to June 2006, now a public interest director of Bank of Ireland) and Doyle (June 2006 to January 2010), who ought to have demonstrated stronger leadership and done more to avoid the collapse of the Irish economy.

The currency devaluation of 1992 and the emergence of the Single European Market enabled Ireland surge ahead economically; experience strong investment and export growth until 2000. Thereafter a property boom took hold powered by low interest rates and cheap credit, much of it sourced outside Ireland. When the property bubble inflated in 2003 in some years more than 80% of annual incremental credit growth went to fund house purchase, construction and property speculation.

The property bubble collapsed in mid 2007 and Government revenue fell by 21% by 2009 but spending on social welfare soared as unemployment grew rapidly. In 2009 the deficit was 14.4% of GDP and last year this rose to 32% of GDP after taking account of emergency assistance to Irish banks.

The Review focused on:

The Department’s advice on the risk of pro-cyclical policy

Their repose to the overheating of the property sector

The nature of the Department’s advice on the vulnerability of the Irish tax system to an economic downturn.

The Review states that the Department of Finance

  • Does not have the critical mass in areas where technical economic skills are required. There are 39 economists in the Department of Finance, less than 10% of the total staff complement. Approximately 60% of the Canadian counterpart to the Department of Finance are economists while 40% of the staff in the core areas of the Dutch counterpart are trained to a Masters, or higher level.
  • Has too many generalists in positions requiring technical economic and other skills
  • It is more number-driven than strategic as evidenced by its failure to set out options to moderate activity in the construction sector, including the introduction of 100% residential mortgages.
  • Does not have sufficient engagement with the wider economic community in Ireland
  • Operates in silos with limited information sharing
  • Is poorly structured in a number of areas, including senior management and there is insufficient attention given to performance management, skill shortages and reporting structures at senior and middle-management levels. The Review comments ‘that as in any organisation there are some who conspicuously underperform causing serious morale issues.
  • Is poor on human resources. Assistant Secretaries do not report to the Secretary-General reporting instead to a Second Secretary General. The review recommends that Second Secretaries-General do not manage large divisions and provide more strategic support.

While officials provided oral advice to the Government on Budgetary Policy in June of each year on the risks of a pro-cyclical fiscal stance the advice was not heeded and spending provisions in the subsequent December Budget in 2001, 2006, 2006 and 2007 was especially higher. This poor budgetary process obscured ministerial and Government accountability to the Oireachtas. Spending marched to the beat of a political drum and the sabre rattling of the so-called social partners.

The review recommends

  1. The creation of a meaningful consultation period seeking broad feedback
  2. Releasing Departmental analysis to the public debate
  3. Providing for third party validation of Department of Finance analysis through an independent Fiscal Council
  4. Greater emphasis on a formal written record rather than oral briefings to Ministers for Finance

The Department of Finance must now remake itself through changes in structure, professional capacity and internal working methods. There has also to be a more outward-looking attitude.

Wednesday, February 16, 2011

Large leap in Irish public sector pensioner numbers

Ireland’s Department of Finance has published the 2011 Revised Estimates Volume which complements the details contained in the 2011 Budget. The following is a summary of the Estimates for this year:

Gross Estimates
(including expenditure from the Social Insurance Fund and the National Training Fund)

 

2010

2011

Change %

Current Expenditure

54,266,425

52,826,910

-2.7%

Capital Expenditure

6,269,216

4,676,500

-25.4%

TOTAL

€60,535,641

€57,503,410

-5%

Net Estimates

 

2010

2011

Change %

Current Expenditure

40,600,479

41,710,547

2.7%

Capital Expenditure

5,918,136

4,341,072

-26.6%

TOTAL

€46,518,615

€46,051,619

-1%

Significant Changes from 2007 to 2011

  • Gross National Product decline by 20.2% from 2007 to 2011
  • Gross Current Expenditure as a % of GNP to rise from 30% in 2007 to 41% in 2011
  • Gross Current Expenditure to increase by 8.3% from €48,798 million in 2007 to €52,826 million in 2011
  • Gross Current Expenditure as a % of GNP to rise from 30% in 2007 to 41% in 2011
  • The number of public service pensioners to rise from 86,780 in 2007 to 124,090 in 2011, + 43%
  • Gross Voted Capital Expenditure to drop by 43% from €8,143 million in 2007 to €4,676 million in 2011
  • Public service employment to rise from 271,858 in 2007 to 302,140 in 2011 (+30,282 / +11.1%)
  • The ratio of public sector staff to public sector pensioners will have increased from 32% in 2007 to 41% in 2011.

Wednesday, September 1, 2010

Mortgage arrears escalate

2009 11 28_1130_edited-1-copy Mortgage arrears in Ireland continue to climbed by close to 40% while the overall number and value of mortgages declined by 0.6%.

Total Mortgages Number Balance Outstanding € Average Mortgage €
Sep-09 794,609 118,648,748,000 €149,317
Dec-09 792,885 118,342,812,000 €149,256
Mar-10 791,047 118,057,227,000 €149,242
Jun-10 789,814 117,717,554,100 €149,045
Change
Sep 09-Jun10
-0.6% -0.8% -0.2%
       
In arrears
91-180 days
Number Balance Outstanding € Arrears €
Sep-09 8,504 1,589,274,000 47,684,000
Dec-09 9,418 1,745,326,000 52,856,000
Mar-10 10,504 1,943,632,000 50,388,000
Jun-10 11,641 2,142,685,000 72,386,000
Change Sep 09 - Jun 10 36.9% 34.8% 51.8%
       
In arrears
180 days+
Number Balance Outstanding € Arrears €
Sep-09 17,767 3,238,39Bal5,000 306,730,000
Dec-09 19,185 3,588,718,000 361,367,000
Mar-10 21,817 4,160,047,000 414,165,000
Jun-10 24,797 4,805,837,000 486,527,000
Change Sep 09 - Jun 10 39.6% 48.4% 58.6%
       
Total Arrears Number Balance Outstanding € Arrears €
Sep-09 26,271 4,827,669,000 354,414,000
Dec-09 28,603 5,334,044,000 414,223,000
Mar-10 32,321 6,103,679,000 464,553,000
Jun-10 36,438 6,948,522,000 558,913,000
Overall Change
Sep 09 - Jun 10
39% 44% 58%

Tuesday, June 8, 2010

Update on the Irish economy

Economic forecasts are emerging that suggest that Ireland has moved slightly from recession.  The number on the Live Register, 437,922, is at a record high as is the national debt.  Interest payments are eating up a much greater proportion of income taxes.

Current Revenue and Expenditure

Exchequer revenue for the first five months of 2010, at €12,293,887, is 10.4% les than for the first five months of 2009

Current expenditure for the first five months of 2010, at €19,535,867, is 3.1% less than for the first five months of 2009.

The current account deficit at the end of May 2010 equated to 59.8% of tax revenue and in the corresponding period it was 47.6% of tax revenue.

Current spending is reducing but tax revenue is reducing even more.

Capital Revenue and Expenditure

The deficit on capital account, at the end of May 2010, €624,759, compares to a deficit of €4,141,336 in May 2009.

Some €3 billion of this change is accounted for by the front loading of a payment of this sum to the National Pension Reserve Fund in 2009.  Job creation is dependent on a combination of advanced technology, reliable infrastructure backed by the investment to sustain its reliability as well as adequate flows of investment capital over a prolonged period.

Exchequer Deficit

The exchequer deficit at the end of May 2010 was €7,866,739, representing an improvement on May 2009 when it was €10,587,645.

National Debt

Our national debt has doubled from €44 billion at the beginning of 2009 to approximately €90 billion at the end of May 2010.

Year National Debt € Million Interest €Million % Income Taxes
2005 38,182 1,720.39 15.2%
2006 35,917 1,859.88 15.0%
2007 37,560 1,618.28 11.9%
2008 50,398 1,543.88 11.7%
2009 75,152 2,547.16 21.5%
2010/5 82,000 1,856.03 43.9%

Interest on National Debt

The interest on our national debt for the first five months of 2010 was €1,856,063 – 15.3% of tax revenue and 23.6% of the exchequer deficit.

Interest on the national debt for all of 2008 was €1,543,383. That represented 3.8% of 2008 tax revenue and 12.1% of the 2008 exchequer deficit.

Conclusions

There is some evidence that we are treading water insofar as some expenditure cuts are taking effect. Tax revenues are still declining compared to the prior comparable period but the rate of decline has moderated from 19% when 2009 as a whole is compared to 2008 to 10.4%.

Welfare spending is 13% higher and the social insurance fund is reportedly seriously insolvent.

Monday, May 24, 2010

Pattern of redundancies spreads across sectors

There were 23,593 redundancies reported in Ireland in the first four months of 2010.  This is comparable to the average annual number of redundancies that occurred in the five years between 2004 and 2008. The level of redundancies increased from 40,607 in 2008 (1.93% of the number at work) to 77,001 last year (3.97% of the number at work).

Some may take heart in the trend of reported redundancies in 2010.  The year-to-year figures for February, March and April show an improvement of 3.7%, 12.9% and 14.6% when compared to the corresponding month in 2009.  But these trends don’t conceal a widening of the sector base, from construction,  in which redundancies are occurring.

Sector spread

 

 

TOTAL

% ALL REDUNDANCIES

Agriculture, forestry and fisheries

378

1.6%

Energy and water

134

0.6%

Extraction industry (chemical products)

126

0.5%

Metal, manufacturing and engineering

608

2.6%

Other manufacturing

4,801

20.3%

Building and civil engineering

5,230

22.2%

Transport and communications

1,075

4.6%

Other services

8,723

37.0%

Banking, finance and insurance

1,460

6.2%

TOTAL

23,593

 

 

Location spread, Jan – Apr 2010

 

 

NUMBER

%
NATIONAL TOTAL

Carlow

244

0.7%

Cavan

189

0.6%

Clare

524

1.6%

Cork

3,000

9.1%

Donegal

438

1.3%

Dublin, city and county

9,422

29.0%

Galway

719

2.2%

Kerry

572

1.7%

Kildare

1,328

4.0%

Kilkenny

409

1.2%

Laois

206

0.6%

Leitrim

56

0.2%

Limerick

1,614

4.9%

Longford

151

0.5%

Louth

423

1.4%

Mayo

316

1.0%

Meath

674

2.0%

Monaghan

278

0.8%

Offaly

331

1.0%

Roscommon

129

0.4%

Sligo

165

0.5%

Tipperary

592

1.8%

Waterford

303

0.9%

Westmeath

538

1.6%

Wexford

538

1.6%

Wicklow

420

1.3%

 

23,593

 

Monday, May 3, 2010

Ireland – Burdened with the highest level of external indebtedness in the world

Ireland now leads the Top-20 nations with the highest level of external debt expressed as a percentage of GDP and that status is unsustainable. 

External debt is a measure of foreign liabilities and in this context includes outstanding and actual current liabilities (not contingent liabilities), including principal and interest, owing by Irish residents to non-residents.

External debt generally falls into four categories:

  • Public and publicly guaranteed debt
  • Private non-guaranteed credits
  • Central Bank deposits
  • Loans due to IMF (if there are any)

The Irish banking sector accounts for $976 billion of external debt and even if this figure was wholly discounted, Ireland would still have the highest debt to GDP ratio in the world – 746%.

External debt has much graver implications that government debt because it is a reflection of how much is borrowed to sustain current living standards. 

Ireland’s GDP has been shrinking while our external debt has been rising.

    External debt % GDP Gross External Debt
$ Billion
GDP
$ Billion
1 Ireland 1,312% 2,320 176.9
2 United Kingdom 425.9% 9,130 2,140
3 Switzerland 382.2% 1,210 317
4 Netherlands 376.6% 2,460 654.9
5 Belgium 328.7% 1,250 381
6 Denmark 316% 627.6 198.6
7 Sweden 264.3% 881.5 333.5
8 Austria 256.2% 827.9 323.1
9 France 248% 5,230 2,110
10 Portugal 235.9% 548.45 232.4
11 Hong Kong 223.1% 627.9 301.6
12 Finland 220.2 402.24 182.6
13 Norway 202.6 553.4 273.1
14 Spain 186.1 2,550 1,370
15 Germany 182.5% 5,130 2,810
16 Greece 170.5% 581.68 341
17 Italy 147.4% 2,594 1,760
18 Australia 124.3% 1,025 824.3
19 Hungary 121.9 225.56 184.9
20 USA 96.5% 13,770 14,260
  Source:
CNBC + World Bank
     

Friday, April 30, 2010

Fingleton’s fantasy at Irish Nationwide is all dust

Irish Nationwide The Irish Nationwide Building Society presented a gung-ho image of its achievement, ambitions, prospects and the calibre of its chief executive, Michael Fingleton, even if the language used to express this was banal and repetitive.

Massive Expansion in Lending

The increase in mortgage lending between 2003 and 2007 was 189%.  This is why taxpayers are being stalked for €2.7 billion in bailout money.  This is why such a high proportion of the assets of this decrepit building society are being dumped on the doorstep of NAMA.  This is why the Irish Government want the citizens to be subdued, indifferent and ignorant.  Ireland’s GDP grew by 36.6% from €139.4 billion in 2003 to €190.6 billion in 2007

Loan growth Bank of Ireland between 2003 and 2007 was 19%; by AIB was 37% and loan growth at Anglo Irish Bank was 37%.

The loan growth at the three Icelandic basket-case banks between 2003 and 2007 was – Kaupthing 72%, Glitner 54% and Landsbanki 57%.

At the benign end of the scale, the Swiss banks must have appeared to Fingleton to have been in a coma.  Loan growth over this 5-year cycle at UBS was 9% and at Credit Suisse

Chicken’s come home to roost

Results for year ended 31 December 2009 reported a loss of €2.48 billion, a requirement for the Irish taxpayer to provide €2.7 billion in bailout funds, a declarations that assets with a book value of €8.7 billion will be sold to NAMA and that 96% of its loan impairment provisions relate to commercial loans.

The Chairman, Daniel Kitchen stated that the problems reported are a consequence of the nature of the operation of the business which was “clearly a flawed model” and that he was sanguine about Irish Nationwide’s capacity to ‘outperform’ (wow), in the short term.  The new chief executive, Gerard McGinn, attributed the lousy performance to the “impact of the lending policies and practices of previous management”.

It is interesting to see how previous management reported their annual results from the time the credit bubble began to inflate on 1 January 2003.

2009 Results

Interest earned from loans was €529.4 million but €324 million of this has not is ‘unrealised’!  Interest paid on customer savings accounts was down 42.3% to €420.8 million.  If the ‘unrealised’ interest were never to materialise, the net interest income of Irish Nationwide in 2009 would be –€215.4 million.

A total of €4.793 billion in debt is due for repayment before 22 September 2010. How can this be accomplished?

Of the €1.189 billion owing to banks, €1.052.3 billion is repayable on demand and the balance in less than three months.

Impaired loans amount to €2.792 billion but only €105.8 million of this impairment relates to Irish residential lending.

“The final losses on the asset portfolio remain highly uncertain”  until each and ever asset is resolved.

 

Demutualisation

While there were 23 building societies in existence when the State was founded that number shrunk to two after the passage of the Building Societies Act 1989 – EBS and Irish Nationwide. ICS Building Society was acquired by Bank of Ireland where it has operated within the Ireland Retail Division – and is about to be disposed of.

One of Fingleton’s principal goals was to demutualise ‘his’ building society

1994 Annual Report: “In order to enhance all the options open to the Society we

continue to seek a change in Section 102 of the Building Societies Act, 1989. On the

basis of the new structuring within the whole State banking and financial sector through the proposed disposal in whole or in part of the TSB Bank, ACC Bank, and

ICC Bank the restrictions of Section 102 are increasingly superfluous and irrelevant.

It is positively discriminatory against the Society, especially in that the Society must

now compete, without any privileges or advantages, with all other financial institutions to whom such a restriction does not apply. It is in the interests of our shareholders and our staff that this Section be amended to reflect the new realities of the market place.”

1998 Annual Report:  “While mutuality is still a relevant concept even if the number of practitioners are reducing (there really are now only two, Irish Nationwide and the EBS) this as we have repeated often before should not be to the exclusion of other options and the Board of the Society has never presumed on behalf of its members to exclude any such option. Indeed that is why we have consistently sought to have Section 102 of the Building Societies Act, 1989 amended to enable the Society to have the same options that are available to other competing financial institutions. We hold no brief for mutuality as an exclusive option. If we were convinced that changing the corporate status of the Society was the correct option for the members and staff of Irish Nationwide we would have no hesitation in recommending this course of action.”

1999 Annual Report “Your Society gave a commitment to review our present and future status during the year in line with market forces and developments. This review was well advanced when we were forced to pause and to reconsider the position in the light of developments in the financial markets and particularly the serious downturn in the share values of the various financial institutions. Suffice to say that everything is on hold at the moment but we will continue to monitor the situation on an ongoing basis.

We have no brief for mutuality as an exclusive option. If we were convinced that changing

the corporate status of the Society was the correct option for the members and the staff of Irish Nationwide we would have no hesitation in recommending this course of action.”

Personal Remuneration

Michael Fingleton enjoyed personal remuneration from Irish Nationwide of €10 million and a personal pension fund in 2006 just shy of €29 million.

Fingleton’s Personal Remuneration
at Irish Nationwide Building Society

2003

€910,000

2004

€1,034,000

2005

€1,269,000

2006

€1,836,000

2007

€2,313,000

2008

€2,417,000

009

€221,000

TOTAL

€10,000,000

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Directors’ Report 2003:  “The excellent results we now report are the strongest yet in the Society’s long history of growth and achievement and significantly enhance shareholder value.

The Society has a strong and effective management team headed by a strong and focused chief executive (Fingleton) whose experience and expertise has produced exceptional results year after year

The Society has improved its cost income ration to a new record low of 21.43%

The Society’s plans for demutualisation have made further progress during the year (2003) and the Government agreed, at the Society’s request, to bring in appropriate legislation to enable the Society achieve a solution which would reduce the uncertainty of future ownership and greatly enhance shareholder value and give the Society the options required to do so”

Directors’ Report 2004

“The excellent set of results we now present clearly reflects the effectiveness of the Society’s strategy that has been successfully implemented and developed over many years.

The success of the Society is reflected in its strong chief executive, its excellent staff, its highly qualified and experienced Board of Directors.

The Board of the Society is fully committed to demutualisation.  The Minister for the Environment, Heritage & Local Government (Martin Cullen) issued a full statement on behalf of the Government on 16 December 2003 announcing the Government approval of a package of measures to amend the current Building Societies legislation, including the removal of the five-year barrier under Section 102.  The proposed legislation is extensive and contains several provisions to enhance the future development of building societies as independent institutions as well as removing archaic unnecessary procedures.

On 15 September 2004 the Minister, Martin Cullen,  wrote to the Society stating “my Department is at present involved in the drafting process with a view to finalisation of the legislation in the Autumn (of 2004)”.  The Board of the Society,of course, welcomes those announcements and statements but is disappointed that the proposed legislation will not materialise until later in 2005.

The demutualisation process must be managed in a prudent, professional and orderly manner in order to maximise the value for the management, staff and (lastly) members.

The cost income ratio was further reduced during the year from 21.43% to a new record low of 20.24%.”

Directors’ Report 2005

“The record results we now report are the strongest yet in the Society’s long history of outstanding growth and achievement.  The excellent set of results reflects the effectiveness of the strategy that has been successfully developed and implemented over many years.

The long awaited legislation is now being drafted and we understand will be published shortly and finally approved before the Summer recess (of 2006).

In the year under review, the Society further improved its cost income ratio to a new record low of 15.18%.

Under the strong leadership of the Managing Director together with a committed and supportive staff, backed by an informed and unified Board, the underlying value of the Society has increased six-fold in the past ten years”

Directors’ Report 2006

“The record results are by far the strongest since the formation of the Society in 1873.

The results demonstrate once again the exceptional financial strength of Irish Nationwide and clearly reflect its strong management together with the effectiveness of its lending strategy developed and successfully implemented over the years.  The Society has developed a successful business model and continues to be focused on our chosen market.

In a year which may well be the last reporting year as a building society, it is appropriate that the Society should present such an outstanding set of results.

Despite relentless opposition from some of our members’ and other vested interests’, the long awaited legislation formally became law in August 2006.  The Board decided to await the publication of the 2006 audited accounts before formally going to the market.  The value of the Society has been enhanced and the net book worth of the Society is up 27% to over €1.2 billion”.

Directors’ Report 2007

“The Board will continue to seek a purchaser for the Society at an acceptable price and will consider all the options open to it to achieve the objective and to realise the optimum value for its members and staff.

The exemplary results we are privileged to report are by far the strongest yet in the Society’s long history of growth and achievement and significantly increase shareholders value with the Society’s net book worth now in excess of €1.5 billion.

The cost income ratio is now at a record low of 10% having fallen from 14.44% in 2006”

Directors Report 2008

“ … was a disappointing year for the Society due to the disruption in global financial systems, the onset of the recession in Ireland and the UK and the resultant downturn in property values. 

Cost control has always been and continues to be a major objective of the Society’s policy.  The 2008 cost income ratio is 17% due to reduced income in 2008 rather than cost increases.

The Board wishes to thank Mr Fingleton for the enormous and unique contribution he has made to the Society over the past 37 years and wishes both Michael and his wife, Eileen, many happy years of retirement”

Directors’ Report 2009

“It is with great disappointment that I have to present to you the accounts for the year ended 31 December 2009 which reflect unprecedented levels of impairment on our loan book which gave rise to losses on a massive scale in the context of the Society.  The collapse of property markets in Ireland and abroad gave rise to the impairments but this was exacerbated by the nature of the operation of the business which was clearly a flawed model.  Final losses on the asset portfolio remain highly uncertain.  The financial results reflect the impact of the lending policies and practices of the previous management.  The scale of losses reflect the failure of the Society’s commercial lending strategy which was over reliant on asset values.  96% of the loan impairment provisions relate to commercial loans.

The Group’s customer accounts decreased by €1.5 billion in 2009 as a result of deposit outflows from the Group’s Isle of Man subsidiary and reflects concerns held by UK investors about deposit security despite the Irish sovereign guarantee.  2010 remains highly uncertain in the context of an industry seeking to define its future structure.”

Mortgage Lending and Mortgage Funding

 

  Total Mortgages
€
Commercial Mortgages
% Total
Customer Accounts
(€ Savings)
2003 4,248,000   3,465,000
2004 5,553,000 35% 4,755,500
2005 7,572,000 32% 5,733,500
2006 10,306,000 76% 6,602,700
2007 12,281,000 80% 7,250,100
2008 10,473,900 78% 6,785,000

Saturday, February 27, 2010

Green shoots of economic recovery tentatively anticipated to materialise by late 2010

The first of the 2010 expenditure cut announcements have been made by Brian Lenihan, Minister for Finance when he indicated that a combination of €3 billion in expenditure cuts and tax increases will be necessary in 2011.  Savings of €2 billion are to be derived from reducing the cost of public services and the reform of income taxation.  Up to €1 billion has been saved on capital expenditure adjustments.

The Government also propose to spend €5.5 billion in 2011 on additional productive capacity. 

Taxation Adjustments

There is little scope for adjustments in marginal income tax rates.  Nearly half of all income earners in Ireland will pay no income tax in 2010.

The PRSI funded social insurance fund is believed to be insolvent.  The Government now intend to a universal social contribution to be paid at a low rate on a wide base.  This will effectively replace PRSI, the Health Levy and the Income Levy.  Water charges are likely to be introduced.

Seeding a return to growth

The Irish Government is anticipating a return to economic growth in the second half of this year with a stronger trend becoming apparent next year, led by exports. Job creation of 25,000 next year and 45,000 annually in later years are projected to meet the job requirements of a society that currently has in the region of 450,000 unemployed persons.

Labour Costs

The Government is quick to point out that Ireland is the only member state of the EU where labour costs are falling (-5.25%) but are more reluctant to mentioned that Ireland ranks 26th among the EU-27 in labour cost competitiveness.  Negative inflation may take some of the sting out of this goal.

Balance of Payments

The Irish Balance of Payments is projected to move into surplus this year following an adverse trend in 8 of the last 9 years.

Unique character of Irish downturn

The collapse of the Irish economy is a consequence of the wholly undisciplined provision of excessive credit.  The Irish population increased overall by 19% in the decade to 2008; the stock of residential units increased by 60% but the credit available to pay for this excess increased by over 500% – all having taken place without effective regulatory supervision by a combination of devious, duplicitous, incompetent retarded morons and dysfunctional imbeciles in charge of banks, all generously indulged with political patronage.  The level of Irish taxation derived from the property sector doubled to over 12% in the seven years to 2006.  Tax incentives for developers, both of houses and commercial properties, such as hotels, led to huge overcapacity as economically illiterate buffoons built more and more shacks without any marketing rationale.

Much of this credit was sourced on the international money markets rather than being derived from customer deposits.  The tax take on these property transactions was very high but it was used to spur an utterly unsustainable level of public spending, especially on welfare – some attributable to unemployment increased but a great deal of it attributable to politicians playing Santa Claus without adequate vetting of welfare spending.  Welfare fraud alone is estimated to cost the Irish Exchequer €1.5 billion in 2010.

Thursday, February 4, 2010

January Live Register symptom of ongoing turmoil

Social Welfare The Live Register at the end of January 2010 contained a record 436,936 persons, an increase of over 175% in the four years since January 2007.

The Exchequer Statement for January 2010 indicates that tax revenue was 21.4% lower than in January 2009. Social Welfare voted expenditure was almost 16% higher and accounted for 22.9% of total voted Departmental expenditure (current and capital) in January 2010 compared to 17.2% in January 2009.

The Social Insurance Fund which is funded by PRSI deductions was anticipated last October to be insolvent by now. It incurred a deficit of €244.7 million in 2008 and was projected to rise to €4.4 billion by the end of this year.

One of these days the penny will drop that it is not possible to sustain galloping social welfare expenditure that completely ignores economic adversity and the consequential capacity to fund same.

For many the combined spend on social insurance and social assistance was of the order of 31% of Government revenue. Last year it was equivalent to 63% of Government revenue.

While the Consumer Price Index increased by 42.4 percentage points between 1998 and 2008 the Index of social insurance related spending increased by 278.1 percentage points and the Index of exchequer spending on social assistance increased by 248.4 percentage points. The number of social welfare recipients increased by over 53% from 436,703 to 669,603 at a time when the general population increased by 19%.

The insured population also increased from 2,310,525 persons in 1998 to 3,091,555 in 2008 but the number in employment as a percentage of the insured population has declined from a high of 73% in 2001 to 69% in 2008. This is significant as employers PRSI contributions are the major funding component.

To summarise ~ between 2007 and 2009:

· Government revenue has declined by 29%

· Social welfare expenditure has increased by 37%

· The Irish population has increased by 8%

· Per capital expenditure on social welfare has increased by 33%

Tuesday, January 12, 2010

Is Ireland’s social welfare system not simply seamless but superb!

There were 2,166,700 persons in the labour force the first quarter of 2007 of whom 1,922,400 were Irish nationals. The total labour force in September 2009 was 1,922,400.

Live Register

Citizen of Jan 2007 Sep 2009 % Change
IRELAND 139,610 346,076 148%
UK    7,545   18,062 139%
EU 15
other than UK and IE
   1,517     4,073 168%
EU 15 > 27    4,198   42,675 917%
Other nationalities    5,882   12,709 116%
TOTAL 158,752 423,595 167%

 

Unemployment

Citizen of Jan 2007 Sep 2009 % Change
IRELAND 76,900 225,200 193%
UK   2,300     9,500 313%
EU 15
other than UK and IE
  1,700     2,400   41%
EU 15 > 27   6,100    29,600 385%
Other nationalities   4,800    13,200 175%

 

The number of persons aged 15, or more, who are not economically active, increased by 8,400 in the case of Irish nationals and 39,900 in the case of non-Irish nationals. The estimated population of persons aged 15, or more, declined by 29,200 in the case of Irish nationals but increased by 197,200 in the case of non-Irish nationals between the first quarter of 2007 and the third quarter of 2009. The total estimated population in this age cohort increased by 2.4% to 3,526,500. The consequence of the foregoing is that Irish nationals now account for 88% of the labour force having accounted for 91% before the onset of the recession.

The 2006 Census of Population indicated that there were 420,000 non-Irish nationals living in Ireland in April 2006 who were from 188 countries. The top-10 of these countries accounted for 82% of the total. 20% married persons from the category EU 15 > EU 27 were married but not living with a spouse at the time of the Census.

Profile of non-Irish nationals

· ⅔ of all Chinese were living in the Greater Dublin area compared to 20% of all Latvians, who favoured large and medium sized towns.

· ½ of the UK and ⅓ of all German resident nationals were living in rural locations.

· The number of single persons was highest among the Chinese and French (72% and 73% respectively) while ⅔ of Nigerians and Filipinos were married

· 13% of Latvian females were divorced and 8% of British males were remarried following divorce.

· Polish males had the highest percentage at work (91%) while 20% of Nigerians were unemployed.

· The Lithuanians had the highest percentage at work in the construction sector (32%) while the US had the greatest proportions in the higher socio-economic groups of professionals and managers.

Irish-national population declining

The population of adult non-Irish nationals living in Ireland is increasing. Despite the number of non-Irish nationals on the Live Register increasing from 19,142 in January 2007 to 77,519 in December 2009, the number of non-Irish nationals aged 15 years and over in Ireland increased from 319,800 in the first quarter of 2007 to 433,000 in the third quarter of 2009. The population of adult Irish nationals is decreasing. There was also a reduction of 29% Irish nationals in this age cohort during this period.

Citizen of Q1 2007 Q3 2009 % Change
IRELAND

Employed
Unemployed
Labour force
Not economically active
Total population aged 15+


1,845,000
    76,900
1,922,400
1,200,300
3,122,700


1,659,000
  225,200
1,884,800
1,208,700
3,093,500






-0.94%
UNITED KINGDOM

Employment
Unemployed
Labour Force
Not economically active
Total population aged 15+


  37,800
    2,300
  40,100
  24,900
  65,000


44,100
  9,500
53,600
36,000
89,600






+37.8%
EU 15 other than UK and IE

Employed
Unemployed
Labour Force
Not economically active
Total population aged 15+


24,000
  1,700
25,700
  6,100
31,800


28,200
  2,400
30,600
  9,200
39,800






+25.1%
EU 15>27

Employed
Unemployed
Labour Force
Not economically active
Total population aged 15+


106,300
  6,100
112,400
  11,700
124,100


122,100
  29,600
151,700
  30,300
182,000






+ 46.0%
Other nationalities

Employed
Unemployed
Labour Force
Not economically active
Total population aged 15+


  61,300
   4,800
  66,100
  32,800
  98,900


  68,500
  13,200
  81,700
  39,900
121,600






+22.9%
TOTAL PERSONS, aged 15+ 3,442,500 3,526,200    83,700
    +2.4%


Are the foregoing trends evidence that, from an international perspective, Ireland’s social welfare offering is especially generous? Has the time arrived for policy makers to adapt it to ensure that it has the capacity to foster self-reliance rather than dependency? Social welfare expenditure will cost €22 billion this year. The social insurance fund, having incurred a deficit of €244.7 million is now reportedly insolvent, possibly to the extent of several billion euro. What steps will be taken to match expenditure with available resources?

Thursday, January 7, 2010

Funding limits will define social welfare goals

Leinster House THE Irish Government is discovering that social welfare and war have some features in common! It is easy to start a war but very difficult to end one! It is also easy to launch, or expand, welfare programmes but when welfare funding capacity tightens beneficiaries are likely to declare war on government if their entitlements are cut, which was the case in Dublin when pensioners revolted in October 2008.

The 2009 Exchequer Statement for Ireland reveals that the national debt had increased by €25 billion in a year to cover a deficit of €24.64 billion.

Irish social welfare spending in 2009 amounted to €21.26 billion, an increase of €3.5 billion (+19.8%) over 2008 and the 2010 Budget provides for the spending a further €660 million in 2010.  This trend is largely attributable to the number on the Live Register increasing from 227,070 to 413,505 and unemployment exceeding 12.5%. There are now approximately 1.8 million welfare beneficiaries in Ireland.

Some €10.7 billion of the welfare expenditure relates to social insurance which is funded by Pay Related Social Insurance (PRSI). The PRSI fund, which had a balance of €3.2 billion at the beginning of 2009 accumulated over the past decade is likely to be now in overall  deficit because of rising unemployment and increased claims for jobseekers allowance and benefit.  The social insurance fund recorded a deficit of €244,718,000 in 2008.  Any shortfall has to me met by the Exchequer through borrowing.

Irish welfare spending increased exponentially in the decade to 2009. The Irish population increased by 19% to 4.45 million but total social welfare spending increased by 183% compared to a rise in the Consumer Price Index of 42.4%.  Expressed as a percentage of gross current government expenditure, social welfare spending increased from 25.9% to 33.4% in 2008 and from 7.5% to 11.4% of GDP in 2008.

Short-term welfare rates of payment have increased  by between 112% and 122%.  Long-term rates have increased by over 100% in the period between 1999 and 2008 – more than double the Consumer Price Index.

Old Age Pensions

A decade ago 75% of all individuals aged over 65 received an old age pension – either contributory, or non-contributory. By 2009 91% of this age cohort qualified for a pension.  The number receiving the contributory State pension has increased from 76,241 persons  in 1999 to 250,117 person in 2008.

Child Benefit and Maternity Benefits

Child Benefit payments have grown four-fold in a decade and are now paid in respect of 1.14 million children.  Maternity Benefit payments have grown 6-fold.

Carers’ and Disability Sufferers’ 

Much of the additional spending went to carers’ or recipients with disabilities. A total of 11,416 individuals received a Carer’s Allowance in 1998 at a cost of €72.89 million. A Carer’s Benefit was introduced in October 2000 for individuals who gave up work to look after an ailing relative. Some 50 individuals received this in 2000 at a total cost of €36,000 By 2008 some 45,818 qualified for the Carer’s Allowance or Carer’s Benefit at to total cost of €483.97 million – an increase in cost of the two programmes in a decade of 563%.

Another are which experienced huge increases related to disability and invalidity. There were 147,158 qualifying individuals for a range of benefits in 1998 but this number increased to 237,651 individuals in 2008.

There is a medical assessment process in place. 43% of applicants were called for assessment in 1998 but in 2008 only 18% of a larger number of applicants were called. Approximately 53% of those assessed are typically deemed incapable of working while the percentage deemed capable of working was of the order of 16-18%. This would imply that if a larger percentage of applicants were medically assessed fewer might qualify for allowances or benefits.

Impact on the Exchequer

Between 1997 and 2007 the cost of social welfare was the equivalent of 26-31% of government revenue.  But in 2008 social welfare spending increased to 43%  and in 2009 to 63% of government revenue.  How can this be sustainable?  Where are the savings to be achieved?  Will political mayhem ensue?

The Minister for Social and Family Affairs refers to welfare funding as ‘an investment to reflect real social progress’  Current spending is not actually investment; it is simply spending.  Ireland’s wage competitiveness is the second lowest in the EU (ahead of Slovakia), according to data provided by the European Central Bank.  The objectives of ‘real social progress’ and ‘inclusiveness’ can only be sustained if the economy manages to sustain an appropriate level of vitality and the capacity to generate output that has value.  The objectives spoken of are not otherwise really achievable.  Where exactly is the country heading if social welfare spending exceeds the Consumer Price Index by a factor of 4?

Tuesday, January 5, 2010

Ireland’s soaring social welfare bill

Social Welfare The 2009 Exchequer Statement for the Irish Government was issued this afternoon indicating the following:

  2008
€000
2009
€000
Change
%
Government Revenue 41,624,097 33,879,322 -18.6%
Welfare Spending 17,815,282 21,260,000 +19.3%
Government Deficit 12,713,821 24,640,971 +93.8%
National Debt 50,400,000 75,152,000 +49.1%

 

Tax revenue for 2009 was €1.357 billion less than forecast last April.  There was some silver lining – corporation tax was €160 million higher than anticipated and this is attributable to foreign direct investors.

Welfare Trends 1989 – 2008

The 20 years between 1989 and 2008 have seen Ireland’s welfare bill grow from €3.38 billion to €17.81 billion.  Expressed as a percentage of gross government expenditure, welfare has grown from 27.3% in 1989 to 33.4% in 2008.

During the decade from 1989 to 1998 the Index of Welfare Expenditure increased by 78.9 percentile points – compared to an increase in the Consumer Price Index of 23.6%

The comparable figures for the decade from 1999 to 2008 saw the Index of Welfare Expenditure increase by 183.5 percentile points in a period when the Consumer Price Index increased by 42.4 percentile points.

 

Welfare Trends 1999 – 2008

The Irish population increased from 3.7 million in 1999 to 4.4 million in 2008, an increase of 19.4%.  This compares to an increase in total welfare spending from €6.28 billion to €17.81 billion.

The pattern of welfare spending has evolved:

 

  1998 2008
Older People 23.6% 24.1%
Widows, Widowers and 1-parent families 18.0% 14.0%
Child Related Payments 9.7% 15.7%
Illness, disability and caring 14.1% 18.5%
Employment support 3.3% 2.3%
Miscellaneous 8.7% 22.1%
Administration 4.9% 3.3%

 

Maternity Benefit changes

Increases in the maximum duration and maximum payment of Maternity Benefit have resulted in significant increases in this category of expenditure.  In March 2006 the maximum duration of Maternity Benefit, Adoptive Benefit and Health and Safety Benefit  claims was increased from 18 to 22 weeks, with a subsequent extension of Maternity Benefit in March 2007 to 26 weeks.

The cost impact of changes in these three categories of benefit is reflected in an increase from €48.79 million in 1998 to €318.09 million in 2008 (+551%).  The number of beneficiaries during this decade has increased from 5,483 to 23,558.

1-Parent Families

The number of beneficiaries of this benefit has shown a significant increase – from 170,927 who received €307 million in 1998 to 233,620 who received €1,067 million in 2008.

Free Schemes

The cost of ‘free schemes’ have also increased significantly

  1998
€000
2008
€’000
FREE ~ fuel, electricity, bottled gas, natural gas, television licence, telephone rental 153,358 584,674

 

 

Funding Welfare

  1998 2008
Exchequer 56% 52.9%
Social Insurance Fund 44% 47.1%
     
Components of Social Insurance Fund    
Employer PRSI contributions 71% 73%
Employee PRSI contributions 23% 20.1%
Self-employed   6% 5.0%
Investment income   2.0%
     
Population of Ireland 3,703,100 4,420,000
Number of welfare recipients    854,000 1,208,800
Number of beneficiaries 1,414,119 1,799,875
Percentage of population receiving welfare 38.1% 40.7%

Sunday, November 1, 2009

Mortgage and residential meltdown in Ireland

2009 11 01_0964_sherry f THE Irish housing market is dead.  The coroner found that a surfeit of 100% and in some instances 100%+ mortgages combined with loans based on ridiculously small income levels to purchase in thistle infested meadows of Ballygobackwards hastened its demise.

The flies are even ignoring its decaying leprosy-stricken corpse.  Stamp duty receipts of €729 million to the end of October are down almost 49.8% compared to a year ago.

The Interim Results from Bank of Ireland for the 6 months ended 30 September 2009 confirm that of the 196,000 residential mortgages it has in the Republic of Ireland, 21,000 of these relate to properties with negative equity involving a quantum of €731 million.  But just 14 properties were repossessed in the six months to September compared to 5 in the previous six months. Impaired residential loans increased by 49% to €342 million during the reporting period.   

The majority of recent mortgagees are therefore, at best, on life support. bewildered by the force of negative equity and unprecedented unemployment levels, wage cutbacks and a collapse in consumer sentiment. The prospect of massive mortgage defaults and repossessions cannot be ruled out.  The mortgage sector is moribund and the blame for this can be laid, in the first instance, at the door of the Central Bank of Ireland whose impact on the economic wellbeing of Irish citizens has been as robust as that of  Mikado, Kimberly or cocoanut cream biscuits  on human nutrition. 

Torrential rain is falling heavily on the parade of maudlin politicians, buccaneering developers and the predatory clown princes and princesses of the Irish banking sector whose malignant vanity and bonus-hunting culture has metastasized the entire Irish economy for at least a decade.  These preening, duplicitous, preening bastards flooded this country with 100% mortgages and are now out to scavenge flesh off the economic corpse.  The income of the average residential mortgage holder is under €58,000.  The size of the average Irish mortgage is €271,000 – a mortgage-to-loan ratio of 4.7:1.

 

2009 11 01_0965_edited-1 The Monthly Statistics of September issued by the Central Bank of Ireland reveals that residential mortgage lending for September declined by €14 million and that September was the sixth consecutive month of decline.  However, when one considers that the total value of residential mortgage debt outstanding is close to €148 billion a drop of €14 million is hardly a drop in the proverbial bucket.  Furthermore, a declining trend over the last six months is a function of how derailed the housing market in Ireland has become rather than a mark of prudence and stability. 

Ireland  has been bewildered with the consequences of toxic debts of the supply side of the construction industry and the passage of legislation to create the National Asset Management Agency to deal with this at enormous cost to the Irish taxpayer. But a significant proportion of Ireland’s 480,000 mortgagees are under enormous personal pressure to maintain repayments of mortgages on houses that are experiencing the consequences of crushing negative equity.  The New Year may herald a tsunami of repossessions and mortgage defaults of an unprecedented scale.  An analysis of mortgage patterns through the EU-27 and the 16 members of the euro currency zone illustrates the appalling extent that Irish citizens were thrown to the predatory wolves by their own Central Bank.

Mortgage ‘Liberalization’

Mortgage liberalization was essentially about letting mercenary yahoos take control while the Central Bank scratched its crotch.  The past 20 years was characterized by a very substantial increase in housing credit that was facilitated by ‘innovation’ in the Irish financial sector.  Mortgage lending was traditionally determined by the basics – disposable income, prevailing interest rates and prudent lending practices based on the deposits of savers.

But the Irish financial sector provided additional funding through access to interbank markets and the increased securitisation of Irish mortgages.  The value of Irish mortgages increased 3-fold between 2000 and 2007 as a consequence.

Formal indicative guidelines on bank lending and the allocation of credit to the private sector were ended by the Irish Central Bank from the 1980’s.

 

Irish mortgage history

Year Outstanding Residential Mortgages
€ Billion
% GDP Mortgages issued
€ Million
1985 6.74 25.8% 880
1990 6.56 17.9% 1,492
1995 11.93 22.3% 2,666
2000 32.54 31.3% 9,004
2005 98.95 61.5% 27,753
2008 147.9 77.1% 15,140

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Ireland compared to EU-27

EU-27
2007

Ireland 2007

Ireland 2009

GDP growth

2.9%

5.3%

-8.7%

Unemployment rate

7.1%

4.5%

12.2%

Inflation

2.4%

2.9%

-6.5%

% houses owner occupied

70.4%

74.5%

Residential mortgage
average loan per capita

€11,250

€32,200

€34,400

Value of residential loans € Billion

6,146.6

139.8

147.9

Typical mortgage rate

5.1%

5.1%

4.5%

 

Ireland and other € countries

 

2007

Total Residential Mortgages
€ Billion

Residential  
Mortgages  % GDP

Mortgage Debt per Capita

Austria

65

23.9%

€7,820

Belgium

121.8

36.8%

€11.530

Cyprus

6.9

44.8%

€8,870

Finland

61.7

34.3%

€11,670

France

651.1

34.9%

€10,170

Germany

1,155.7

47.7%

€14,050

Greece

69.3

30.2%

€6,210

Ireland

139.8

75.3%

€32,200

Italy

304.2

19.8%

€5,130

Luxembourg

13.8

38.5%

€29,030

Malta

2.0

37.6%

€4,940

Netherlands

558.9

100%

€34,140

Portugal

101.0

62.1%

€9,520

Slovakia

6.5

11.9%

€1,120

Slovenia

2.6

8.0%

€1,320

Spain

646.6

61.6%

€14,510

 

The 16 central banks of the €-zone countries face similar constraints insofar as none of them determine local interest rates.  But Ireland has managed to increase it mortgage debt, per capita, from €5,650 in 1998 to €32,200 in 2007.  Expressed a percentage of GDP, residential mortgage debt in Ireland increased from 26.5% in 1998 to 75.3% in 2007 and will be even higher in 2009 given that GDP will contract and residential mortgage debt has increased by €9 billion since 2007.  The stock of housing units in Ireland has increased from 1,173,000 in 1998 to 1,883,303 in 2007 but many of these are located in remote and inconvenient places in incomplete housing estates.  Does this not suggest utter dereliction of responsibility on the part of the Central Bank of Ireland?

The residential mortgage debt of The Netherlands is equivalent to 100% of GDP.  But the owner occupation rate there is only 54% but this has increased from 43% in 1983.  Like Ireland, Holland experienced a sustained period of house price increases.  This occurred between 1996 and 2001.  Since then prices have risen at a more moderate pace – 4%-5% per annum.

The Dutch authorities introduced a Code of Conduct for Mortgage Lenders in 2007 that has led to a considerable tightening up of the lending criteria by limiting lending at high loan-to-value ratios and putting a ceiling on mortgage-to-income ratios.  Should the Irish Central Bank follow suit, or do they care?  The new Governor will have to transform the Central Bank quickly and successfully if there is to be any chance change for the better.